The Delaware Court of Chancery, in United Food and Commercial Workers Union and Participating Food Industry Employers Tri-State Pension Fund v. Mark Zuckerberg, et al. and Facebook, Inc., C.A. No. 2018-0671-JTL, opinion (Del. Ch. Oct. 26, 2020), dismisses derivative claims challenging director defendants’ agreement to support a stock reclassification that would provide nominal defendant’s founder with permanent voting control — a transaction that was abandoned after being challenged in a prior lawsuit — for failure to make demand, finding that directors could believe in good faith that the founder’s permanent control was in the company’s best interests, and rejecting plaintiffs’ argument that directors’ affiliation with venture capital firms overcame Delaware law’s presumption of director independence based on venture firms’ reliance on “deal flow” from the founder.
NEW: Morris James discusses the decision in Chancery Questions Utility of Aronson Test, Dismisses Derivative Suit of Facebook Stockholder for Failure To Allege Demand Futility.
Paul Weiss discusses the decision in Delaware Court Of Chancery Provides New Guidance On The Standard For Analyzing Demand Futility.
$$$ Law360 discusses the decision in Facebook Ruling Highlights Risks Of Flawed Board Processes.
$$$ Fried Frank discusses the decision in Facebook Decision Highlights Risks of Back-Channel Communications with a Controller.
Tulane Law’s Ann Lipton discusses the decision in Not All Heroes Wear Capes.
UCLA Law Professor Stephen Bainbridge discusses the decision in A brief essay on Delaware Vice Chancellor Laster’s Argument for Replacing Aronson with Rales.
$$$ Law360 discusses the decision in Chancery Tosses Suit Over Facebook Stock-Shuffle Plan.
Wachtell discusses the decision in Delaware Reaffirms Director Independence Principle in Founder-Led Company.
$$$ Delaware Business Court Insider discusses the decision in Facebook Shareholders Can’t Bypass Board to Pursue $90M Case.